EECG Industrial Solutions

Actuators

Electric vs Pneumatic Valve Actuators: Which One Should Industrial Plants Choose?

Valve automation depends on the plant's process, utilities, control architecture and operating environment — not on a universal preference for electric or pneumatic actuation.

Aug 20267 min readEECG Engineering Team
AUMA electricPneumaticScotch YokePart-turn

Valve automation in industrial plants

Manual valves can be suitable for local isolation, but many industrial plants require automated valves for remote operation, process sequencing and control. EECG's product portfolio includes both pneumatic actuator solutions and AUMA electric actuator technologies.

What is a valve actuator?

A valve actuator is a mechanical device that operates a valve, converting energy into mechanical movement so a valve can open, close or move to a required position. Actuator types include electric, pneumatic and hydraulic.

What is an electric valve actuator?

An electric actuator uses an electric motor to produce the torque required to operate a valve, and suits applications requiring remote operation, automated opening and closing, position control and integration with control systems. EECG's AUMA portfolio includes multi-turn actuators, part-turn actuators and gearboxes.

What is a pneumatic valve actuator?

A pneumatic actuator uses compressed air to generate mechanical movement, which is useful where a reliable compressed-air supply is available and rapid valve operation is required. BDK's portfolio available through EECG includes pneumatic and Scotch Yoke actuator solutions.

Electric vs pneumatic actuators

FactorElectric actuatorPneumatic actuator
Energy sourceElectricityCompressed air
ControlElectricalPneumatic / electrical control
Plant requirementElectrical supplyCompressed-air supply
AutomationExcellentExcellent
SpeedApplication dependentOften suitable for rapid operation
MaintenanceApplication dependentAir-system maintenance required
Fail-safe optionsApplication dependentConfigurable depending on system

When should you choose an electric actuator?

When should you choose a pneumatic actuator?

Actuator ranges

Multi-turn actuators

Designed for valves that require multiple rotations for operation. EECG's AUMA portfolio includes SA and SAR multi-turn ranges.

Part-turn actuators

Designed for valves requiring limited rotational movement, including suitable quarter-turn arrangements. EECG's AUMA portfolio includes SQV and SQRV ranges.

Scotch Yoke actuators

A Scotch Yoke mechanism converts linear force into rotational torque and can be used for quarter-turn valve automation where torque characteristics are appropriate.

Actuator selection checklist

Valve automation by industry

Power plants use automated valves across steam, water, cooling and utility systems, while steel and cement plants use them in utilities, process lines and cooling systems. The operating environment influences actuator selection and protection requirements.

Conclusion

Electric actuators suit electrical control and precise positioning; pneumatic actuators are advantageous where compressed air is available and fast operation is required. For plants in Raipur, Bhilai, Korba and Bilaspur, actuator selection should always begin with the valve and process requirements.

Need help specifying instruments, valves or a maintenance contract for your plant? Our engineers can review your process conditions.

Talk to an engineer →

Related articles

How to choose the right industrial flow meter 8 min read Radar vs ultrasonic level transmitters 7 min read RTD vs thermocouple temperature sensors 7 min read Industrial pneumatic components explained 6 min read